What is a bigger issue?

[Anonymous]

Guys, would you be more likely to date a girl who is overweight, or a girl who has a little bit of a limp when she walks. And I realize that personality does play into it, and so does chemistry. But I also know that physical appearance has an influence on all of us. I'm just wondering what you guys think.

Updates

+1 y

For the sake of this I would say:


Girl A is 15-20 lbs overweight with a pretty face


Girl B is attractive and athletically toned with a slight limp due to a past sports injury


Both are cute, witty and have great personalities.

[christian2724]

Depends what you mean by "overweight". I like a little extra. I don't know the exact BMI threshold I consider unattractive.

I'm going to guess you mean obese. In which case I'll go with the girl with the limp.

I really don't see a limp as a big deal at all. I'm almost indifferent about it. I'm pretty accepting with weight as long as she's proportional.

[sfauo]

Terrible question to answer without sounding a bit shallow ha ha but id say perhaps someone overweight, exercise is always available for all of us :). But someone with a limp would be OK too, like you said personality is the key though

[Habakkuk]

assuming in all other respects they were equal, I'd take the one with the limp, because I'm skinny and overweight just isn't gonna work for me, however a lot of girls think they're tubolards when they are like 115 so...

[Habakkuk]

as per update, I'm going with the girl with the limp

[Anonymous]

Limp? I wouldn't have an issue dating a woman in a wheelchair, much less a limp. lol As for being overweight. I am a little overweight myself. Neither are an issue for me.

[Opinion Owner]

@update. They both sound hot to me.

[Snar87]

how overweight? a few pounds ? or obese?

If it's obese, then I'll take the girl with the limp.